A cash offer is not a random discount. It is the home’s fixed-up value minus the repairs, the cost of holding and reselling it, and a margin for the risk the buyer takes on. Here is how that math works, with a real North Sacramento purchase as the example, so you can see where each part of a cash offer goes.
The formula behind every cash offer
Every legitimate cash buyer works from some version of the same math:
Offer = fixed-up value (ARV) − repairs − holding costs − resale costs − margin for risk and profit
- Fixed-up value (ARV): what the house should sell for once it is renovated, based on recent sales of comparable renovated homes nearby.
- Repairs: the full renovation the buyer will pay for after closing, from paint and flooring to roofs and systems.
- Holding costs: property taxes, insurance, utilities and upkeep for every month the buyer owns the house before it resells.
- Resale costs: agent commissions plus escrow and title fees when the buyer sells the finished house.
- Margin: the cushion that covers surprises and the market moving, plus the buyer’s profit.
If a buyer cannot walk you through each of those numbers for your house, that is a red flag. See our guide to how cash offers are worked out, and how to choose a buyer.
A real Sacramento example: Longshore Court
Longshore Court is a 5-bedroom house in North Sacramento that we bought as-is, renovated with our own crew, and resold. The owner sold after a family loss, with no repairs, cleanout or showings. Two things from that deal show the formula at work: the renovation came in under budget, and the market slid while the work was underway, so the house resold for less than the fixed-up value we projected when we bought it. For the family’s side of the sale and 13 before-and-after photos of the house, see the Longshore Court case study.
Holding costs — taxes, insurance, and utilities while we owned it — plus escrow and title fees on both transactions come out of the margin before any profit. In other words, the gap between the purchase price and the fixed-up value is not profit.
The renovation coming in under budget is the rare case. When a renovation runs over, the overage comes out of the buyer’s margin — never the seller’s.
The risk is real, and the buyer absorbs it
At Longshore Court, the comparable sales supported a higher value on the day we bought. Then the market moved, and the house sold for less. That shortfall came straight out of our margin, not the seller’s. The seller had the full agreed price, with no repairs, no showings, and no market risk.
Part of the “discount” in a cash offer is the price of certainty. When you list, you keep the risk — and you keep paying the mortgage, taxes, insurance, and upkeep while you wait.
The ARV on paper is not the price you get
The ARV is calculated on the day of purchase, but the sale happens one to three months later, and a lot can change in that time:
- Price at the full ARV and the house may sit on the market while holding costs pile up and the market moves against you.
- Price at a discount to the ARV and the house usually sells faster, which keeps holding costs down.
There is no formula that spits out a single percentage for every house. The offer depends on the house, the repairs, the market, and the buyer.
Why offers are built on conservative numbers
Buyers budget repairs above what they expect and holding periods longer than they hope, because the padding is insurance against exactly what happened at Longshore Court. But an offer padded too far stops being competitive. The buyers who can offer the most are the ones with the least uncertainty — their own crew, volume pricing, their own capital, and a track record of closing. Different offers usually reflect different levels of risk, not different levels of generosity.
The commission you pay either way
Resale commissions run about 5% in total, including at least 2.5% to the buyer’s agent. Even if you list the house yourself, you still typically pay 2.5% to the buyer’s agent. A cash sale skips commissions on the seller’s side entirely. We cover those.
How a margin this thin works at all
- Our own crew. We renovate with our own team, which keeps costs down and the schedule tight.
- Volume material discounts. Buying materials across many projects at once gets us pricing a one-off renovator cannot match.
- Our own capital. We do not borrow hard money, so there is no lender taking 10–12% interest while the house sits.
Speed matters twice over: it cuts holding costs and it gets the house sold before the market can move against it.
What makes a cash offer higher or lower?
- Repairs: a house needing $15,000 of work leaves far more room than one needing $75,000. Houses that need serious work, including repairs we price as-is, are where a cash sale often makes the most sense.
- Location and resale demand: a house in a neighborhood where renovated homes sell quickly is worth more to a buyer than one where they sit. That is true across Sacramento as much as anywhere else we buy.
- How long the resale will take: a longer hold means more taxes, insurance, and utilities eating into the deal.
- The buyer's structure: a local buyer with their own crew and capital can pay more than a national formula buyer or a wholesaler who needs a second margin for the end buyer.
Want a second opinion on any offer you have received — ours or someone else's? Call (916) 507-2502 and we will walk through the math with you. No obligation.
Want a number for your own house? Get a free, no-obligation cash offer, or read how a sale to us works, start to finish. You can also call Kevin at (916) 507-2502.
Frequently asked questions
How much do cash home buyers pay compared to market value?
It varies with the repairs and the risk, but the math is consistent: the fixed-up value minus repairs, holding costs, resale costs (about 5% commissions plus closing fees), and a margin. At Longshore Court, the market slid between our purchase and the resale, which shows why the margin exists.
Why is a cash offer lower than what my house could list for?
A list price is not what you net. Listing means retail repairs, about 5–6% in commissions and fees, months of mortgage, tax, insurance, and upkeep payments, and no certainty that the house will sell. A cash offer moves those costs and the market risk to the buyer.
Do cash buyers really pay no fees or commissions?
We do. Insightful REI charges no fees or commissions and covers standard closing costs. The offer we make is the amount you receive at closing.
Can I see how you calculated my offer?
Yes — ask us. We calculate every offer from your home's fixed-up value, the repair scope, and resale costs, and we are happy to show the numbers, the same way we have shown them on this page.
How fast can you close, and does speed change the price?
We can close in as little as 7 days, and no — a faster closing does not reduce the offer. The timeline is yours to pick.
What if my house needs major repairs or has code violations?
We buy in any condition — heavy fixers, hoarding situations, code violations, and fire damage. The repair cost is factored in transparently, using the same formula.